When I'm looking for pizza that tastes a little more homemade than Pizza Hut (my chain-restaurant pizza of choice), I get Antonio's. Their pizza has never disappointed me, and the people that work at the Broadview Heights location are friendly. I only had a time-issue with them on the day of the Super Bowl - I showed up on time and had to wait about 25 minutes, but I guess I'm willing to forgive that. All other pick ups were ready on time. I'm crazy about cheese and they use a LOT of it on their pizzas, so it's pretty much a match made in heaven.
Note: this isn't a dine-in place. They have one table inside, and I think it's merely decorative. I think the one in Parma is the only dine-in.