Now that I have been here a couple more times, I can say that the Tremont Tap House deserves a 5 star review.
The atmosphere is really cool and comfortable - a place you can hang out at night and have great beer, or a brunch joint where you stroll in with the same clothes you had on from the night before.
This place is beer-centric, which appeals to me big time. But the food is very unique and amazing. I can definitively say that the pork belly nachos were the best nachos I've ever had. The black bean puree was so good I felt like putting it on my face like war paint as I devoured the nachos with my bare hands. Despite being pork belly nachos it was not nearly as heavy sitting as I would have expected.
This place has about everything I want in an establishment and its all done a bit differently and very well. Can't wait to be back.