Since moving to Charlotte in early 2011, Tinder Box has become my number one stop for good cigars. They have a huge well kept humidor room, helpful staff, and most important some really great cigars.
One of my favorite things about this place is that every employee seems to be a seasoned cigar smoker. They are rather friendly, and verily astute regarding their products. If you have a friend or loved one whom is a cigar smoker and you, yourself are not, these folks can help you.
The prices are on par. Again, the selection is extensive. The only thing I don't really like about it is the location. It is in the basement of the South Park mall, hence, it can be hectic finding a place to park sometimes.
I have been smoking cigars for a couple years and have been to a lot of cigar shops in a lot of cities. Some with better selections. Many with better parking, but rarely any with collective experience and helpfulness of the folks at tinderbox.