I think the rave reviews led to me having especially high expectations for this place. Came with one other person on a Thursday, and shared some of their most popular dishes: duck fat frites, New England style mussels, and crab cakes. Nothing was bad, but also nothing was really amazing. The duck fat frites, which are SUPER popular (both of the tables on either side of us also ordered this) were good, but I think I've had better/more fragrant ones at other places. These were basically just like regular fries. The mussels also were good - the broth was tasty and flavourful without being too salty, and there was a good portion of mussels. I wasn't a huge fan of the crab cakes because I found them slightly spicy and really they were just mediocre. Beer drinkers can rejoice though because they do have a very large selection of beers with some really unique ones.