3.5 stars, but rounding up because I'm feeling generous. I am very finnicky when it comes to burgers (everything is judged against Burgatory!), so Burger Bar Crescent was just okay for me. It was good, but not amazing. I would go back and maybe try something else (I had the Yosemite Sam burger with sweet potato fries) to see if they can wow me. Portions were ample, which is always nice. What really jumped out at me was the great service. I've noticed a lot of the places I have dined at in Montreal have pretty awful service, but not Burger Bar. Our server was SUPER helpful and bent over backwards to make sure we were satisfied. I was impressed that they have 19 crimes red blend on their wine list, which is one of my favorites that I've never seen on a restaurant menu before. They have indoor and outdoor seating and heat lamps on the balcony. If you don't mind getting some secondhand smoke from people puffing away below, definitely sit outside for a great view of the action on the street while you dine!