I'm a fan of the Reds in the financial district and last night, I found myself at the midtown location for the first time. The service was lovely and attentive, no complaints there. I ended up ordering off of the summerlicious menu b/c some of the offerings looked delicious.
I started with the quinoa salad with apples and aged cheddar. This was fantastic - completely exceeded my expectations. For my main, I ordered a fried chicken dish with beet/cauliflower salad and this spicy chili sauce. It was SO spicy, which I enjoyed, but I can imagine it being way too hot for the average person. The chicken was incredible. The other 7 people at my table opted for the steak or fish, and many were jealous of my pick. For dessert, the chocolate pot de creme with chili was a bit of a let down. Could not taste the chili at all.
I think Reds is simply a good option, anytime. It's a great place to go if you want food that is a bit more inventive without being too out there. I love the decor - the glass, leather and wood. It's really pretty, but not dainty.