A solid 4 I think. Genevieve's dedication to her craft is shown in the inventive and frequently changing menu as well as the "Iron Cupcake" competition she organises. I've seen her in action at that and she was full of enthusiasm!
The cupcakes seem to be mainly their 3D cupcakes-bun+frosting+filling. They're very tasty and I love the flavours she has chosen but I do kind of wish there were more 2D cupcakes. Sometimes all you want is a simple cupcake done really really well. I'll have to go back and try more of them to give a full assessment. I really enjoyed my PB & C cupcake. I'm not quite so sure about the chocolate ganache filling in the red velvet. I rarely turn down chocolate, but there's something lovely and fresh about red velvet when it's not messed with and it's what I'd prefer.
My biggest test was ordering 24 mini cupcakes for a baby shower. I initially asked a few questions by email and Genevieve was quick to answer. We sorted out the final order by phone. She was very obliging, and in the end I decided on a mix of chocolate, vanilla and red velvet buns with pink and blue frosting. I had 3D decorations on just 6 of them because I was on a bit of a budget! The minis were $1.45 each and I think it was $3.45 each for the 3D decorations. Total came to around $45. I asked to collect them on Saturday and they were ready and waiting when I got there. The frosting on each was perfect and they were exactly as described. We all loved the fondant decorations-including the 1 year old guest at the shower who thought one of the pacifiers was real and whipped it from the top of a cupcake before running off with it. All in all I think they were a hit!