I see the mixed reviews and honestly don't get it. It's casual but good food, large portions and a friendly staff. After 3 visits I feel like a regular with the bar staff. The pool table is free and usually available if you are looking to hang out a bit. The bathrooms are pretty bad and could use a facelift. Only reason for not getting 5 stars.
The lobster roll sliders are awesome. Claw meat and big chunks of it. 3 sliders are enough to share one and still have enough as a main course. My companion raves about them to her friends.
My favorite item is the Mussels. Priced a few dollars more than most places but you get twice as much as any place. A heaping pot full. There a 4 or 5 variations to choose from. Bring an appetite or order them for the table.
I haven't had the oysters yet but am anxious to try them soon.