3.5ish for me. I really loved this place...except for the service, which really dragged the place down on both visits. The food was fantastic and the portions were larger than I'd anticipated. The bread selections were delicious. The seafood sampler was top notch. The décor was pretty and comfortable at the same time. We were upstairs and practically had the place to ourselves. Which is why I was so sad about the SLOOOOOOWWWW service. Everything from drinks to food to boxes to the check took a long time and it just seemed like our server showed up at all the wrong times. They were polite and all, but absent a lot and not super on top of the flow of service. There is parking across the street and a coat check at the door, but plan to be there a while.