I would really go for a 4.5 star on this one but I did not genuinely have an issue. The only semi-negative thing was that our server was a little "over the top." Meaning, this person kept referring to us as "loves." It was just a little out of the ordinary. But as far as water refills were concerned, they were on top of it and we also ordered a bottle of wine that was refilled for us promptly.
So! Here are the good things:
LOTS of different options and variety. It is a little mix of modern American and Italian. Between the three of us we ordered:
Caprese Salad
Crispy Gnocchi
Shrimp Po Boy
Fish Tacos
Beet and Apple Salad
All of which were excellent and had no issues. You can tell the ingredients are fresh and delicious. The price was less than $10 for each dish which was great. Keep in mind that these items are all "appetizer" size compared to other restaurants.
Anywho, I am all for supporting local businesses that aren't a chain. Definitely give this place a shot. We will definitely be back.