I eat here at least 3 times a week - it's becoming a problem. My roommate and I are here so often we always ask about their "IPO" (Italian Public Offering). Cannolis are the currency of the future.
I would highly recommend the Beef Cheesesteak - it is my all time favorite. The Caprese Salad is a staple in my diet as well. The mozzarella is homemade and to die for. Other recommendations include: II Purista, Vegetarian Lasagna, Chicken Marsala, Chicken Pesto Salad, Portobello Sandwich and Grilled Cheese.
Don't forget to order a cannoli.
It's for your health.