I came here for my very first dinner in Madison. It's definitely a really "sconnie" spot, and they serve some local staples, like curds, pretzels, and the like.
We started with the giant pretzel, which was......... a giant pretzel. I debated for a long time between the Wisconsin cheddar mac and the chicken pot pie, but ultimately went with the cheddar mac because it had Wisconsin in the name (and because I'm pretty sure the pot pie had mushrooms, which I am deathly afraid of). The mac and cheese came with another pretzel and tasted like mac and cheese tastes... maybe a little better.
I feel bad for giving three stars, because my experience here wasn't bad, but wasn't memorable either. It was also at a work event, so unfortunately couldn't drink. I think I'll need to give this place another try sometime soon and order something a little more exciting with a side of wisco beer. This is another one where I'd take someone who was visiting for the weekend to have a real Wisconsin experience.