Hidden Harbor for the win! What a gem. We were in town for a wedding and made reservations for the following Saturday with the newly married couple. It was perfect, the running joke was that they were on their honeymoon. It's so beautifully decorated, you almost forget you're in Pittsburgh and not on some island enjoying tiki drinks living the good life.
We ordered the jerk chicken tacos, jerk chicken nachos, fish tacos, and a tuna pokè bowl. All of the ingredients were fresh and tasty. We especially enjoyed the nachos. The frozen drinks and craft cocktails were amazing too. They carry over 200 types of rum, which was really cool. I had never been to a rum bar before that. They offer rum flights if you're not sure what you like.
I can't praise the waitstaff, cooks, and hosts enough. They were very accommodating. At first we requested a booth but realized the tables hit below our knees, then we asked if we could move to a high top. They were very nice about it. I just didn't want to eat my nachos and poke bowl awkwardly like that. Those booths are perfect for having drinks.
You can tell they put a lot of thought into all aspects of the business. Loved it and can't wait to return.