So this place gets four stars because the staff has been great, the drinks are cheap, and the pizza and wings are exactly what you'd expect.
I bought about 4 rounds of drinks and food for 6 people and dropped maybe $60-70 max.
The place is usually pretty relaxed, and the bar staff are quick to help you and they make a nice strong drink as soon as they recognize you (or you tip them well, like at most places).
The food does leave a lot to be desired, but you're making a mistake if you're going to Dahmen's for a nice sit down dinner.
Dahmen's is a fun little bar that just so happens to serve pizza and good breadsticks.