Ah, The Old Fashioned. This is Madison... and Wisconsin, too. I think of the food as Wisconsin staples, one step up. The ingredients are local and fresh, and I always leave happy. I'm a fan of the walleye sandwich and Green Bay chili in particular.
The bar and beer selection is absolutely fantastic... well, save for that one "import" brew from Minnesota :D I kid. Grab a beer, an Old Fashioned, anything you'd like, and just enjoy.