4.5 stars.
I bought a Groupon for this place (after checking the great reviews on Yelp) and went last night with my wife and a neighbour. We had the following;
Aloo Gobi Masala...9.99
-Potatoes and cauliflower in Indian gravy
Mutter Paneer...10.99
-Peas and cottage cheese curry
Dal Makhni...8.99
-Home-style black lentils
Kathirikkai Kara Kulambu...8.99
-Spicy and sour eggplant curry, goes well with rice
They were all very good and had distinct flavours. The eggplant was quite spicy (hot). There were plenty of cheese cubes in the mutter paneer. We also had an order of plain rice, plain naan and raita.
My mango lassi was excellent. Very thick and mango-y, without being overly sweet.
The only weakness occurred when we ordered Papadum as an appetizer. There were three of us, and she brought 2 papadums. Weird.
It is clean, has nice decor, and is worth the drive to Scarborough.