I thought I would never find an ice cream treat I enjoy more than Graeter's back home in Ohio, but I recently discovered Rita's and I think it has eclipsed Graeter's (at least for the time being) as my ice cream obsession.
I go here at least once, twice a week. I have earned two free Rita's treats in the last two months using their club card. There is just something about the Gelati; the combination of the citrusy, tangy italian ice with the sumptious and rich vanilla custard that keeps me coming back. I crave it. It's incredible. My favorite is Wild Black Cherry and Vanilla custard. Try it!
Don't try: The Slenderita. Just don't do it. Don't half-ass your trip to Rita's...save up your calories if you have to ;-)