This is probably more of a 3 star place, but I'll give them a 4th star for consistency, which is so rare at bakeries usually. We've been here at least 10 times and afterwards I always have the same takeaway: it's good enough that I'll go back when convenient, but it's not the best ever. We are usually very happy with the plain flavors like chocolate with vanilla frosting. Those tend to be an excellent execution of a basic item. Some of the more adventurous flavors aren't that successful. And the fruit flavors, like the raspberry, taste too strongly of fake flavoring. I'd definitely recommend skipping that one!