I love the location, atmosphere, and decor of this place. I really want to like it but...ugh....it's just not well run. I was there over the weekend and nobody could decide who was supposed to serve us. Took forever to get served. Finally....we got a Bloody Mary...and oops...they forgot the bacon slice. Isn't that part of the signature bloody? Also, the olive was just grotesque. Instead of green...it was mostly brown like it was rotten or something. Then we got the deviled eggs with salmon. No salmon. They said it was on the inside. Hmm....never found any. We got a couple of salads after that. Ingredients missing. A waiter gave us excuses about how they didn't expect a crowd today. Wow. ok. Too many other good choices in Old Town. I'm done trying Montauk.