A Madison classic serving "classic" Italian food as in the same things they were serving 3 decades agon when I was a student living in Madison. Now, my tastes in Italian run more to the authentic and less to Americanized food that defined these type of restaurants when Italinan food was considered "ethnic" and "exotic."
While it is a great festive atmosphere, especially after a football game, the food is fine but not something I'd go out of my way for.