What a let-down !!! We recently moved within walking distance to the Pony and could not wait to give it try. Once and DONE. Shrimp in the Cocktail were at least 2 days old, not fresh steamed at all, like "rubber". Pizza was "BLACK" on the entire bottom, burnt and overdone, cheese was like bubblegum, by no means a high quality mozz. The sausage on the pie was bland and nothing special. What a shame, because they did a great job on the renovation. Don't get drawn in by the eye-candy. With all the great places in town this joint needs to up its game big time !!!