4 stars is about right ... It's good and we'll go back but not great. I swear Mac's used to be better, before they became a "chain". Seems like they lost their luster when their sauces went into prepackaged bottles. Service was friendly and OK. A little slow with the check which matters with young children (they get impatient and start bouncing off the walls). It always seems a little loud but maybe I'm a prude. Kids did like the food though which gets a lot of points from us. Solid 4!