I have only been here once and can't even remember specifically without looking at a menu what I ordered. But, it was among the best hamburgers I have ever had in my life!
I have been to a few sports bars for football games as such and the food is always what you would expect out of sports bar. And while I'm not sure if Hickory Tavern is considered a sports bar or not, the food is certainly above par for what you would expect out of similar places.
I have no problems going back.