I love Mother Fool's...
As a barista myself, this IS my all-time favorite spot in Madison. The Baristas here are consistently friendly. -Despite the hipster atmosphere the Baritas don't act "cooler-than-you" than extremely helpful, friendly, and they earn their tips!
As for the coffee, i honestly say i enjoy it the most out of anything.
I always get a flavored Latte but once while talking to the barista he forgot to ask what flavor i wanted and made my latte plain,
which was something i'd never get by choice.
But it was awesome! He had taken his time to steam the milk to perfection and i could take the quality of the espresso instead of the sugary syrup flavor i've been "enjoying" my whole espresso-drinking experience.
Don't even get me started on the food products. All bakery items are vegan?!?!?! I'm in. And they're never too-dry or stale. They're delicious and nothing i can get anywhere else.
I love that they partner with local bussinesses like The Green Owl Cafe and Ladonia Cafe. Those are also, high quality eats, in my books.
All in all, this place is DEFINITELY my cup of tea. I'm a regular.