I would consider myself a pretty good judge of BBQ and Bobby Q was some of the best I've had. The St. Louis ribs were fall off the bone tender and incredible. Brisket, tender and flavorful. Cornbread? Scary addictive. My only complaint would be that the Mac and Cheese tasted like it was out of a Kraft box. Guess you gotta cut costs somewhere.
I think a good judge of who knows their shit on BBQ on yelp is whether someone like Joes Real BBQ or not, apologies if you think that place is good but it just isn't worthy of the praise it gets.