5-Star because it is the only restaurant that offers really South Indian food in Madison. It adds much diversity to Madison's food scene.
We tried Dosa and Uttapam. They are REAL!! Get a Ghee dosa. It would be both a month-opening and eye-opening experience if you have never tried it before.
Fish curry was a very memorable dish. We also tried things under the "Chettinadu" category. Good stuff.
They have a incredibly long menu. It will take maybe 10 visits to savor the full selection. For first few visits, I suggest sticking to things you can't find in other Indian places in Madtown.
Based on our two dinner visits, both food and service is pretty good. I hope this new establishment on the west side will thrive in the coming years.
CAUTION: The "Hyderabadi Dum Chicken Biriyani" is insanely spicy. I like spicy food in general and take on very spicy dishes. But this dish will be over the limit to most people. Consult before you order.