I like that four stars means "Yay! I'm a fan" because that's exactly how I feel about this place. It definitely isn't the best around Madison, but it isn't anywhere near the bottom either. I've been hear multiple times and always enjoy the atmosphere, although on game days it can get really loud and crowded (but I suppose that's to be expected!). The salmon burger is an excellent go-to there. It's topped with some sort of delicious coleslaw and some other fantastic flavors. My husband gets it every time. Sometimes I wish their menu was larger which is a rare thought for me. I don't know why I think that - maybe because I'm not always as excited about the options as I hope I'd be. Regardless, I would recommend this place....just good luck parking.