To all of those negative reviewers: Stop expecting this place to be something that it's not. Not everything has to be a hipster/gastropub/artisanal/mixology/tapas/whatever bar. This is your quintessential low-price, neighborhood eatery. Carmella's is a great place for the average Joe to eat classic bar food and American-Greek/American-Italian at rock-bottom prices. That is their menu style and they do a great job in that genre. If you like basic thin-crust pizza + wings and beer, this place is for you. Tuesday nights they have pizza for a dollar per slice and Wednesday nights they have $0.50 wings. They have drink specials every weeknight. The "Barbalo" wing sauce is a mix of buffalo and barbecue sauces and pretty tasty. Our favorite server is Carly. She is very efficient and sweet. Carmella's is lucky to have her. If you go, please treat her well!