My daughter and I are pizza aficianados and decided to try NYPD Pizza. This was the closest location to us, so last Thursday, we ventured over.
I ordered a 4-item special pizza with pepperoni, sausage, onion, and anchovies (all self-respecting Italians have anchovies on their pizza). My daughter order a calzone. It all went downhill from there.
My daughter's calzone arrived burnt literally BLACK. Complaining to the manager was an exercise in futility. He was rude and dismissive.
My pizza was pretty good, but expensive. My daughter managed to scrape enough burned crust off her calzone to eat it. She said it was otherwise OK, but had too much ricotta cheese.
I want to note that the restaurant staff were friendly and cheerful. But the manager soured the entire experience. Apparently, the manager feels that they have more than enough customers, so engendering goodwill is not necessary. We will not be returning. Red Devil Pizza is every bit as good, if not better - and they will bend over backwards to make good on anything that is wrong.