I came in here after reading a post on a food blogger's website about their "amazing" soft serve. I came in excited to try their "Cereal Milk" ice cream. My friend tagged along and ordered their "Double Double" soft serve. They brought us out ice cream in cups slightly larger than a shot glass. I was pretty annoyed since it cost us over $7. It would have been fine if the ice cream was good, but we both thought it tasted disgusting. Almost as if it had been made with sour milk (though I'm sure that's the way it was supposed to taste). The ice cream tasted so strong-- not creamy at all. Neither of us finished ours and needless to say, we won't be returning.
I think it's also important to mention that, aside from the soft serve, Momofuku Milk Bar only sells packaged baked goods-- nothing fresh (they bake it in New York and send it over).