Toby's is an institution in my life, and last year I came here with a group of buddies for old time's sake. Though I love it, I've always recognized it as being awful... but you know what? I'm getting soft in my old age. I'm going to update this review to three stars.
Half price chicken wings on week nights, cheap beer (even Bone Shake was $14/48ounce pitcher) and nice service. Is it still a really sterile, strange giant student pub with club music on weekends and horrible karaoke on Mondays? Yes. But it's A OK by me.