Man, was I expecting much more.
First the good: even with peanuts EVERYWHERE the place felt pretty clean and inviting. A shoot sends peanuts to the tables with possibly unnecessary force which makes them explode a bit when they reach your table...which I guess is pretty fun the first time around.
Now the rest: We got the Barrie Burger and the Mad Sconie Burger. The Barrie has peanut butter, bacon and cheese. I bit into it and immediately put it down and opened it to make sure it actually had peanut butter in it. Yup. It did. Weird. Nothing really stood out in terms of flavors. Pretty much tasted like a cheeseburger. The Mad Sconie burger which comes with fried pickles, bacon, better beef burger and spicy cheese bun was also tasteless and "uninspired". This is the award winning burger, so either this was an off night or someone hasn't tasted Old Fashioned Burgers.
Finally our waitress was not very friendly. Kept on having conversations with other people while we were clearly waiting for the check for a while and trying to flag her down. Oh well.