It's everything you love about the original location, plus better lighting, more space, and easier parking. I stopped in on a Friday evening around 5 or so to pick up a dozen donuts to share with my boyfriend's family while camping with them that weekend.
While heading over I was a little worried the selection would be picked over due to the later hour/lack of college students needing donuts at all hours of the day but the cases were full and the donuts were fresh!
I got two each of the caramel, raspberry, and strawberry Rabbi's Delights (filled crullers), then let my boyfriend round out the order with two cinnamon rolls, two Fruity Pebbles donuts, and two Oreo bismarcks.
Service was friendly and the counter person answered all my BF's questions about what was what. The donuts were packed perfectly so nothing got squished on our journey and everything lasted to the next morning without drying out. Quality and flavor is identical to the Regent Street location.
I have many fond memories of the original location and it's a little closer to my home, but I think in the future I'll be more likely to pick up donuts from the east side while running errands near the mall or heading to a movie in Sun Prairie.