We stopped here one night after I noticed that they were the "Hot New Trending" business on Yelp! We walked in on a Sunday about 30 mins before closing and received (IMHO) stellar service.
We were greeted by the owner who was patient enough to give us an overview of the selection process and the toppings (not every topping is self explanatory; he's got a varietal of meats and sauces and could suggest what works best together). After we ordered, our slices arrived about 15 mins later and it was well worth the wait. The artwork on the wall tells a story of it's own which will have you staring off while you chomp down on your meal.
There is no way to come up short in a place like this. The options are in abundance from the toppings to the sauces. You drive what goes in your mouth here. Either select from a creation on the wall or craft your own masterpiece.
It was definitely nice to buy slices vs. an entire pie, even though you have can do that as well. Doing so allowed us the chance to explore their menu options without the commitment of an entire pie. Mr. B. and I love pizza and will definitely keep My Slice of the Pie on our list of contenders.