I'm not particularly fond of thrift or vintage shops, so fortunately for me - though not for my wallet - Better On You is neither of those. I drop in every few months to either drop off items to consign or to see what's newly arrived on their shelves. There hasn't been a single visit where I have been unable to find at least one item that comes home with me! The size of the store isn't too massive, so you can get through it reasonably quickly without feeling overwhelmed by the selection. There's no need to be wary of quality level, as they are pretty discerning about what they take into the store.
Shopping tips: Join the mailing list to receive coupons! Don't forget to check the very back corner where the handbags are stashed. There's free parking out back.
Consigning tips: They recently started accepting items by appointment only, so plan ahead. That I'm aware of, this is one of the only (or the only) shop with a decent selection for men. I love the fact that I can check my account balance online.