Um, I love this place. First time there and I can't wait to go back. We saw it as we went into Hidden Harbor and decided to check it out afterwards. As much as I liked HH, this is my kind of place. It was dark and hipster-ish? But also not? Haha. It wasn't very busy for a Saturday night, which from the reviews, is unusual, so I am considering myself lucky. We scooped up two bar stools and felt right at home.
I got the Permanent Yard Sale by Brew Gentlemen (phenomenal) and my friend got a Manhattan. He said it was the best Manhattan he's ever had! He chatted up the bartender afterwards, very social and polite.
Definitely check this place out! Fantastic bartenders and great selections.