Tried it again last week - done with this place. 16" pie had the topping of a 10". 2-3" wasteland of empty soggy crust around the edge, thin on the cheese and sauce & few lonely peperoni. Sad but looks like quick trip has become best pizza option in Waunakee.
Best pizza in Waunakee only makes Zoe's the tallest midget by default.. I think they've got worse since they moved to new location. Understand expenses but they kicked prices up fair amount too. Delivery or take out - open the box before you or the driver leaves. Decent baked spaghetti and I think their Trenton Tomato is good when you get it there .