I'd probably give it 3.5 but I'll give them the bump. The service was good. We had a party of 16 and the waitress did a fantastic job.
The atmosphere is in a huge old church in Polish Hill. I ordered the BBQ Pulled Pork with fries. I thought the portions were a tad small but that's ok.
The beer I had was their Irish Red. It was excellent. I'd highly recommend it. The other people at my table enjoyed their beer as well. All the drinks looked delicious.
My only slight gripe was we were there for a birthday and brought our own cake. They cut our cake for us but then charged every person in the party $2 for doing so. So, that's $32 for cutting the cake and putting it on a small plate? That's crazy. I think that should be free considering we dropped close to $800 as a group. Oh well.