Yum! The pizza at NYPD is awesome but first I have to rave about the garlic knots. These little nuggets of joy are bread knots cooked to perfection and soaked in olive oil and garlic.
I've never actually gone for any of their specialty pizzas because I like pretty basic pizza -- cheese, pepperoni, black olives, etc. You also have to try their cold cut sandwich. My mom is part Italian and this reminds me of sub sandwiches that she used to make when I was a kid.
All in all it's a great dining experience and really good for families.