I've dined here several times since they've opened. I can't say I've had a bad experience. The service can be spotty, but generally it's pretty decent.
I agree that the menu is limited, but I believe most people should be able to find something to enjoy. I've tried a variety of items:
The burger (good)
Spaghetti and meatballs (very good - homemade pasta that is, yes, cooked al dente)
Half rotisserie chicken - tasty, and I'm not a huge chicken fan
Special BLT type of sandwich at lunch - EXCELLENT
I've also heard from other diners that all of pasta dishes on the menu are very good.
The only dessert I've tried is the pineapple upside down cake, and it's been good.
For a non-alcoholic treat, try their Ginger-Lime Iced Tea. It's amazing!
The wine list is more limited than I would like, but I suppose it matches the menu variety. :)
The atmosphere is nice, the front desk staff is always super-friendly, and the location is really convenient for me. I do consider this one of my regular local restaurants and recommend you give it a try.