I come to Brooklyn Pizza once or twice a month and my usual order is two slices of pizza with mushrooms. The pizza is pretty good and very reasonable in price. The service is always great. I decided to try something different yesterday and went with angel hair and meatballs. When I placed the order, I told them to go light on the sauce.
A few minutes later, my order came. I saw a fairly large plate of pasta with two decently sized meatballs. A good amount of steam was coming off of the pasta. So far, so good. When I looked closer, I saw that there was a ton of sauce on the pasta....not what I wanted. The meatballs looked a bit strange. I may be wrong, but they did not look homemade (they were near perfect replicas of each other on the outside), and the inside of them looked very processed-looking. Neither the sauce (which was a-plenty) nor the meatballs had much taste to them and I poured on a ton of grated cheese and crushed pepper to doctor the dish up a bit. Moreover, the meatballs were both cold. I told the server and she brought me over another meatball. You guessed it- it was a clone of the other two and it also was cold.
Next time I go, I will stick with the pizza and avoid the pasta.