This is one of those places that I don't really venture far from what I like. I mean, if it's not broke, why fix it??? Right?
At any rate, The Funghi pizza is the way to go. that stuff is pure pizza gold. The Manzo/short rib pizza was alright, but the broccoli rabe adds such a bitter taste to the pizza that it masks any taste from the short ribs (which were also not as tender as I'd like). My friend ordered the Butcher sandwich, which she loved but it was really small. The fries were amazing, though!
I've also had one of the pasta specials, and another girlfriend really loved their butternut squash soup. Overall, really love this place! Just be prepared for a long long wait if you come on the weekends!