This is one of the best quality values & best kept secrets in the area. The 5 stars are based on the type of place this is - friendly, casual, neighborhood, quality/creative food. The food is always prepared fresh and the menu is creative. The daily specials are also worth a look. Have been here dozens of times over the years and is always my best "go-to" place. Take friends and out-of-towners here too. Everyone seems to like this place. Lunch or dinner.
The final and best part is the mayor of Killington's - Frank. He's the best. Every time you enter (if he's working) you get a personal greeting and a friendly story! Not the same if Frank isn't there, because it wouldn't be possible. Will miss him when he decides to just enjoy Jack Daniels on his porch with his wife & daughter & an official full retirement!