I have to admit that I've never set foot in Davis Bakery. I've never tried anything that didn't come off a deli tray.
But let me tell you that what I have tasted from Davis is amazing. Quality meats, cheeses and breads. The best potato salad I have ever had. And those pickles??!!! You can tell they're homemade and if you like a more cucumber-y (that's totally a word. Right?) pickle, you have to check it out.
We order from them for work events and they are always easy to deal with, reasonably priced and very accommodating. I live on the west side but have considered picking up for personal events too. I highly recommend!