We first tried mellow mushroom on a Groupon, and now we're regulars. The red skin potato pie is AMAZING (but make sure to ask for spicy ranch on the side if you're wimpy like me).
We normally get take out, and they aren't always super speedy to get to the side door (might need a bell) but food is very GOOD! We also liked their BBQ Chicken pizza and Spinach Dip.
Today, a slow Sunday, we had a problem with our pizza being too spicy (forgot to ask for no spicy ranch). Hubby called the store after we realized our mistake, and they made it right. Customer service - heck yes! The team took care of us and were friendly and professional from start to finish.
Oh, and did you know they have gluten free crust and vegan cheese?!