This place has delicious, fresh bagels every day. The cream cheese is smooth and plentiful. They have wonderfully flavored cream cheeses and freshly made bagel sandwiches. The staff is friendly and cheerful.
With all this going for it, it's a shame that accuracy is so lacking. Four of my last five visits, I got home to discover they got my order wrong. The wrong type of bagel or the wrong cream cheese or not toasted, whatever you can get wrong on an order of two toasted bagels with cream cheese. Thankfully, all the bagels are fresh and yummy. I'll just have to start checking my order before I leave, but I'll keep going to Poppyseed's.