Many people have asked why I would go to Richmond Hill for a pizza when there are many reasonable options in Toronto. This place came on my radar because of the sheer number of people who have reviewed it on another website and liked it.
I went for takeout but their new dining room looks very elegant yet casual. I went in around 4:30 midweek and couldn't believe how busy they were. They were quick to observe new patron and took orders promptly. Aside from myself there were about 10-15 people waiting and they appeared to be having trouble keeping up with phone orders despite 2 staff taking phone orders. Although they were extremely busy, the wait for take out orders was a reasonable 20 minutes at most.
I am not a vegetarian but have a 'thing' for vegetarian lasagna and don't see it on a menu as often as I'd like. This lasagna had lots of fresh vegetables and homemade noodles. The portion filled one of those aluminum take out containers with sauce just sneaking through the top. It was accompanied by an unexciting dinner roll and butter. I also ordered a pizza with spinach and extra cheese. They do not skimp on the toppings and all the ingredients seemed fresh. My main problem with this place was the tomato sauce seemed like your everyday, non-exciting, American tomato sauce. Not that fresh, homemade tomato sauce that I was expecting and looking forward to eating.
Price point is reasonable, certainly cheaper than some of their competitors. I doubt I will go out of my way to eat at this place again but if you lived inn the area and looking for good pizza, I would recommend giving this place a try.