So first I find it hilarious that this place has been around for how long and only has 27 reviews. But upon further thinking, if the average age of the customer here is what maybe 55+...then the use of Yelp is probably semi-lacking, haha. But anyways. We came here last night with neighbors because we live in Waunakee and we were pretty sure its like a Waunakee icon so a visit needed to happen. It was exactly what I expected, "charming" old school supper club decor, with food that was edible but nothing that blew me away. However, my husband's medium-rare Steak Oscar was cooked fantastic and was probably the best part of everything on the table. My broiled haddock and baked potato were alright but nothing I couldn't do at home. The fun part about a supper club is the soup and salad bar that comes with your order. I did enjoy their turkey & rice soup and the salad bar section was your average. Definitely can't say I'm dying to return but I am glad we gave it a shot and can say we supported a local biz!