If I could give 4.5 I would. Best Italian in Madison the 4 years I've been here. The truffle meatballs on special were to die for, and even the ziti and tomato sauce (which must have been homemade) were delicious. My wife got the lobster ravioli, and I had major food envy. The cream sauce makes me salivate just thinking about it, and the ravioli were packed full with lobster. No skimpin here. Pretty pricey, but the lobster ravioli was worth every penny. Look for them on Groupon! The only downside for me was ambiance.