Meh is right. I usually mesh with Yelpers but have to agree to disagree on this one. We were excited by reviews but disappointed by experience.
STARTERS: Pretty sure I found the worst margarita in the world. Ever. It was bland and flavorless, literally like water. Hubs had the rhubarb drink and liked it. The fried olives were interesting but now that I've experienced will probably never need again. There was an abundance of olives but the bread and dip steal the show. Also had the bruchetta and pardon the 51% Italian in me for saying that SHORTRIBS do NOT belong on BRUCHETTA. It's called a sandwich and needs to be moved to that part of the menu.
ENTREES in our party included margharita flatbread and chicken marsala. I felt like neither was to write home about, just average, so-so meal.
DESSERT went with the pumpkin whoopee which had a lot going on on the plate: chai ice cream, pretty solid; pumpkin whoopee was good, but missed that certain something; with the highlight being a gingerbread something puree. Puree was a show stealer, rich in flavor but certainly not a standalone. Maybe serving it with shortbread cookies or something but way too much with everything else on that plate.
My recommendation: This is one nook and cranny you may not need to explore. Price doesn't align with product and I think they're trying too hard to be different. There are too many great options in Phx to pay a premium for mediocre. Move on friend, move on.